How to Criticize

Criticism is an important aspect of intellectual discourse, and it is crucial for critics to take responsibility for their critiques. In many cases, the burden of proof and accountability lies with the target of the criticism. However, there are situations where the target may be incompetent or the responsibility is unclear due to multiple claimants. In such cases, it is beneficial for critics to step up and take responsibility themselves. This approach ensures that individuals with the necessary competence and ability to provide clear evidence are the ones shouldering the responsibility. By doing so, we can avoid futile arguments and promote a more constructive discussion based on the principle of Noblesse Oblige.

A fascinating perspective on this matter is that individuals who have studied mathematics possess a unique ability to define concepts for themselves, more so than the general public. Therefore, it would be ideal for them to say, "The definition is ambiguous, so let me define it instead." It is disheartening to witness individuals who simply adhere to definitions created by others without critically evaluating them. This lack of logical reasoning skills is often seen as a deficiency. If one possesses superior logical reasoning skills, they should be able to create appropriate definitions through trial and error. Hence, the saying, "If the Definition is Unclear, Define It Yourself." holds true.

For further insights on this topic, you can refer to the tweet by @genkuroki: .